Updated information on "Positivity problems and
conjectures in algebraic combinatorics"
- A solution to
Problem 2 for convex polytopes was given by Kalle
Karu, with a strengthening
by Paul Bressler and Valery A. Lunts.
- Some progress
on Problem 4 is due to Victor Reiner and his
colloborators Naichung Conan Leung, Dennis Stanton, and Volkmar
Welker. The paper with Welker is also related to Problem 20.
- The conjecture following Problem 9 is false as stated. Pavlo
Pylyavskyy pointed out that if λ ≥ λ' then it may not
be the case that |Πλ| ≤
|Πλ'|, the smallest example
being λ = (6,2,2,1,1) and λ' = (5,3,1,1,1,1). The
conjecture remains open if modified to state that
φλ has
full rank when λ ≥ λ', though this may very
well be false. The original conjecture remains open in the case that
would imply the Foulkes plethysm conjecture, viz., λ has
m parts equal to n, where n ≥
m. However, a counterexample in that case was announced by
J. Müller and Max Neunhoeffer, but details have not yet
appeared. Update: see the addendum in the paper
"Some computations regarding Foulkes' conjecture" by J. Müller
and Max Neunhoeffer, Experimental
Mathematics 14 (2005), No. 3, 277-283.
- A solution to the conjecture of Sundaram mentioned shortly after
Problem 9 was found by Ben Joseph in April, 2000.
- A solution
to Problem 13 (the nonnegativity of the coefficients
of the (q,t)-Kostka polynomials) has been given by Mark
Haiman.
- Problem 23 was solved
affirmatively by Maria Chudnowsky and Paul Seymour in 2004.
- Problem 5 has a negative answer. I don't remember the
reference.
-
A negative
answer to Problem 6 was found by Art Duval, Caroline Klivans,
and Jeremy Martin.
- A positive
answer to Problem 7 was found by Kalle Karu.
-
A negative
answer was found by Petter Brändén for general
(i.e., not necessarily natural)
labelled posets. Subsequently John Stembridge gave a
negative
answer for naturally labelled posets.
- Problem 24 was given a positive answer by
Petter Brändén, James Haglund, Mirkó
Visontai, and David Wagner.
- Problem 25: update forthcoming.