A smooth plane quartic over Q with at least 166 rational points, with no automorphisms over Q̄ and a Jacobian whose endomorphism ring is Z. It is a plane section of a quartic model of the K3 surface of discriminant −163, found by a census of planes on models of that surface that have no automorphisms. The 36 lines of the surface give 36 of the points. Lines through pairs of known points turn these into 153, and conics through five known points give the last 13. Both steps can be checked in your browser.
A smooth plane quartic is a non-hyperelliptic curve of genus 3. The most rational points we have found in the literature for one is 144, on a curve of Elkies that has the involution x ↦ −x [1]. Curves with automorphisms are easier to fill with points, because each point brings its whole orbit. An earlier phase of this project found the quartic
with 256 points. Its automorphism group is dihedral of order 8, and the points form 32 orbits of 8. The curve of this note has no symmetry at all, and each of its points had to be found. We know of no smooth plane quartic over Q with trivial automorphism group and more known points. Our check of the literature is limited to [1] and to web searches, and proves nothing.
The curve lies on the quartic surface S ⊂ P3 given by
This is a smooth model of the K3 surface of Picard number 20 and discriminant −163, the surface behind Elkies' records in genus 2 and 3 [1] and behind the companion notes [2], [3]. S contains 36 rational lines and 210 rational conics. The curve is its section by the plane
parametrised by (X : Y : Z : T) = (−x + 6z : 3y + z : 2x − y + 2z : x + 2z). Substituting gives 4 times the quartic at the top.
Rational curves on S force rational points on its plane sections. A plane meets each line in one point, which is rational; on this plane the 36 points are different. A plane meets a conic in two points, the roots of a quadratic, and they are rational for some planes and not for others. On this plane they are rational for 31 of the 210 conics. That gives 55 points, one of which is also on a line. So the surface forces 90 points on this section: the blue and orange dots.
A quartic model of the K3 surface is a class H with H2 = 4 in its Néron–Severi lattice that embeds the surface in P3. The models from the earlier phases of this project all have an automorphism, a reflection. A plane that avoids the centre of the reflection still gives a curve with no forced symmetry, and the best such section we found has 148 points. The models used here have no automorphism at all.
We sampled 4,224 very ample classes and kept the 3,895 that no automorphism of the lattice fixes. These are classes, not yet models: many are equivalent. Those with at least 32 lines make up 1,439 different models. We computed the equations of 1,437 of them, each with its complete lists of lines and conics, and searched 1,114. The 323 that were not searched have 32, 33 or 35 lines and a coefficient of absolute value above 60. The surface above has 36 lines and coefficients of absolute value at most 68.
On each model we scored every plane aX + bY + cZ + dT = 0 with integers of absolute value at most 60, about 108 planes, by its number of forced points; this takes about 19 microseconds a plane. The best planes, at most one in 200, were closed under chords and tangents. Sections that reached 110 points were counted to height 104, and those that reached 128 were searched further: to height 106 in several coordinate systems, and with conics. On the plane of this note the first closure gave 153 points, the count to height 104 gave 156, the further search 162, and conics the last four.
Every candidate was then put through the automorphism test. Altogether the search produced 98 different curves with at least 140 points and a certified trivial automorphism group.
Known points produce new ones in two ways. A line through two known points meets the quartic in two more points, which are rational when a quadratic has rational roots; the tangent at a known point does the same. Start from the 36 points on the lines of the surface and repeat this. Four rounds give 153 points and a fifth gives nothing. Starting from all 90 forced points gives the same 153.
The second way uses conics. A conic through five known points meets the quartic in three more points, the roots of a binary cubic, and each rational root is a new point. Conics cut out a linear system of dimension 5 and degree 8 on the curve, so the three points are the effective divisor in the class 2K − (P1 + ⋯ + P5), where K is the canonical class. This is the plane quartic's version of the four-point rule for genus 2 [2] and of the five-point rule for hyperelliptic curves of genus 3 [3]. It reaches points that no line through two known points reaches.
Each of the 13 remaining points lies on a conic through five of the 50 smallest of the 153. For example, the conic through (0 : 1 : 0), (2 : 2 : 1), (1 : −3 : 0), (6 : 2 : −1), (9 : 9 : 2) passes through (54560 : −12838 : −2189). With these 13 the list is closed: chords, tangents, and conics through five of the 60 smallest points give nothing more.
The program below repeats both steps in your browser, in exact integer arithmetic. It starts from the 36 points on the lines, adds every rational point on a chord or tangent until nothing changes, and then checks, for each of the other 13 points, that it lies on the stated conic through five points already found.
Hollow: not found yet. Blue: the 36 starting points. Green: found by chords and tangents, lighter in later rounds. Purple: on a conic through five points found before.
| statement | status | how |
|---|---|---|
| at least 166 rational points | proved | each point satisfies the equation exactly, and the points are different (checked again when this page loads) |
| the curve is smooth | proved | the ideal of F and its partial derivatives has dimension 0 over Q; the curve is also smooth modulo 7, 11, 17 and 19 |
| no automorphisms over Q̄ | proved, twice | first, an exact computation of the automorphisms modulo 11 and 17, from the flexes, leaves at most an involution; an involution would make the Frobenius polynomial at 7 have a repeated factor modulo 2, and it has none. Second, by Torelli's theorem an automorphism of a non-hyperelliptic curve gives an automorphism of its Jacobian other than ±1, and the next row excludes that |
| End(J) = Z over Q̄ | proved | at p = 7 and 19 the Frobenius polynomials are irreducible, and no ratio of two of their roots is a root of unity. Their fields have only the subfields Q, a real cubic field and themselves, and the two cubic fields differ (discriminants 49 and 473) |
| J(Q) has no torsion | proved | #J(F7) = 1561 = 7 · 223 and #J(F11) = 4608 = 29 · 32 are coprime |
| exactly 166 rational points | not proved | a search to height 106 in several coordinate systems found nothing outside the list. The rank of J(Q) is not known |
| no plane quartic without automorphisms is known with more | not proved | we found none in the literature; see Records |
The Frobenius polynomials are T6 + 11T5 + 59T4 + 195T3 + 413T2 + 539T + 343 at 7 and T6 + 19T5 + 169T4 + 915T3 + 3211T2 + 6859T + 6859 at 19.
The search, the computations and this note were produced by a team of AI agents: Lor (Claude Opus 5.5, Anthropic) led the project, with Claude and GPT agents as researchers, engineers and reviewers. This revision of the note, with its figures, was written by Claude Fable 5.2 and checked against the project's files. The team worked under the direction of Andrew V. Sutherland, who posed the problem and supervised the work.
(0 : 1 : 0) (2 : 2 : 1) (0 : 1 : −3) (1 : −3 : 0) (1 : 0 : −3) (6 : 2 : −1) (7 : 3 : 0) (7 : 7 : 4) (2 : 8 : 1) (9 : −2 : 0) (9 : 9 : 2) (2 : 2 : −11) (3 : 11 : 2) (11 : −3 : 9) (5 : 12 : 5) (13 : −9 : 1) (5 : −7 : −16) (15 : 16 : 3) (0 : 14 : 17) (0 : 18 : −1) (22 : 4 : 19) (25 : −12 : 9) (25 : 24 : 7) (9 : −16 : 27) (11 : 29 : 10) (14 : 30 : 3) (11 : 32 : 25) (32 : 3 : −9) (34 : −14 : 25) (16 : 37 : 17) (18 : −28 : 39) (17 : −7 : −44) (54 : −26 : 7) (60 : 58 : 21) (28 : 63 : 34) (12 : −66 : 19) (66 : −4 : 3) (70 : −6 : −17) (30 : −48 : 71) (29 : 74 : 7) (12 : 74 : 75) (3 : 23 : −76) (65 : 81 : 12) (88 : 27 : 4) (36 : 94 : 33) (100 : 42 : 1) (90 : 104 : 17) (41 : −109 : 58) (110 : −54 : 57) (114 : −56 : 57) (114 : −20 : 3) (115 : −53 : 26) (119 : −42 : 93) (123 : −2 : 6) (124 : 54 : −3) (129 : −21 : −23) (31 : −140 : 47) (140 : −67 : 49) (146 : 140 : 97) (175 : 111 : 142) (190 : 162 : 141) (201 : −199 : 12) (89 : 206 : 127) (60 : −222 : −1) (225 : 29 : 12) (235 : 49 : −58) (94 : 244 : 23) (284 : −61 : 2) (287 : −148 : 31) (300 : −22 : −75) (50 : −208 : −319) (387 : −181 : 108) (130 : 406 : 103) (413 : −42 : −96) (430 : 88 : 371) (455 : 84 : −117) (165 : 478 : 139) (490 : 6 : 423) (494 : 194 : 13) (93 : −322 : −516) (33 : −518 : 75) (603 : 248 : −51) (605 : 587 : 151) (666 : 662 : 399) (690 : 196 : 33) (723 : −579 : 50) (147 : 797 : 786) (802 : −686 : 53) (70 : −854 : 143) (890 : 312 : −135) (891 : −488 : 87) (913 : 348 : −111) (682 : −938 : 31) (608 : −1219 : 16) (1245 : 497 : 1056) (530 : 1284 : 855) (1578 : 152 : 1365) (880 : −1743 : 1261) (140 : 1641 : 1818) (1830 : 978 : 1519) (1952 : 42 : −549) (578 : 1956 : 425) (2054 : 116 : 107) (2148 : −967 : 1469) (2162 : −1512 : 165) (1204 : −1830 : 2193) (2346 : 2032 : 1725) (910 : −552 : −2361) (804 : 2534 : 237) (2562 : −602 : −75) (2565 : −36 : −703) (2610 : 118 : 135) (2795 : 1134 : −258) (940 : 3358 : 329) (3474 : 4216 : 645) (4365 : −2566 : 390) (1347 : 5047 : 516) (5271 : −1084 : −637) (5535 : 88 : 4779) (3210 : −6486 : 4585) (2030 : 7086 : 1443) (7743 : −4045 : 816) (8041 : −1688 : −913) (288 : −8062 : −81) (2023 : 8073 : 969) (1036 : −8414 : −103) (9709 : 6739 : 7742) (12710 : 12432 : 8091) (15105 : 6548 : −159) (8773 : 16798 : 1771) (782 : −17022 : −189) (5170 : 18996 : 1903) (20520 : −8309 : 15228) (22617 : −5243 : −1404) (23430 : −11228 : 8305) (11891 : −18763 : 27025) (18655 : 31489 : 3577) (10208 : 32502 : 3045) (33380 : −25093 : 2414) (11590 : 38868 : 8601) (42880 : 25998 : 35041) (46151 : −21228 : 9899) (21994 : −50934 : 31065) (54560 : −12838 : −2189) (5550 : 15042 : −58349) (30010 : 80346 : 7533) (35002 : 86682 : 33741) (88145 : −12811 : 2992) (30330 : −146628 : −1249) (166662 : 2920 : −46781) (168610 : −36008 : −18031) (235053 : −118247 : 26784) (305361 : −415984 : 14013) (388722 : 626864 : 73473) (188025 : 696952 : 123261) (1119670 : 1462758 : 205639) (2311175 : 953156 : 36883) (2674154 : −1292200 : 342113) (4612393 : 4462668 : 3012729) (6312380 : −3135237 : 742599) (2697149 : 6388905 : 2746848) (8339243 : −15986565 : 12027486) (17777477 : 17737242 : 10386431) (17957226 : −2297946 : −3810025) (234946359 : 230213323 : 94637500) (1286041472 : 3839690670 : 1057598289)
Each of the 13 points that chords and tangents do not reach, with five of the 153 points that lie on a conic with it.
(2565 : −36 : −703) on the conic through (0 : 1 : 0) (0 : 1 : −3) (11 : −3 : 9) (14 : 30 : 3) (54 : −26 : 7) (12710 : 12432 : 8091) on the conic through (0 : 1 : 0) (2 : 2 : 1) (13 : −9 : 1) (25 : −12 : 9) (28 : 63 : 34) (15105 : 6548 : −159) on the conic through (0 : 1 : 0) (6 : 2 : −1) (7 : 3 : 0) (0 : 18 : −1) (25 : −12 : 9) (46151 : −21228 : 9899) on the conic through (0 : 1 : 0) (2 : 2 : 1) (0 : 1 : −3) (1 : −3 : 0) (28 : 63 : 34) (54560 : −12838 : −2189) on the conic through (0 : 1 : 0) (2 : 2 : 1) (1 : −3 : 0) (6 : 2 : −1) (9 : 9 : 2) (88145 : −12811 : 2992) on the conic through (2 : 2 : 1) (7 : 3 : 0) (9 : −2 : 0) (2 : 2 : −11) (16 : 37 : 17) (235053 : −118247 : 26784) on the conic through (0 : 1 : −3) (1 : −3 : 0) (13 : −9 : 1) (25 : 24 : 7) (17 : −7 : −44) (2311175 : 953156 : 36883) on the conic through (0 : 1 : 0) (0 : 1 : −3) (1 : 0 : −3) (11 : −3 : 9) (100 : 42 : 1) (2674154 : −1292200 : 342113) on the conic through (0 : 1 : 0) (1 : −3 : 0) (7 : 7 : 4) (65 : 81 : 12) (114 : −56 : 57) (8339243 : −15986565 : 12027486) on the conic through (0 : 1 : 0) (6 : 2 : −1) (11 : −3 : 9) (5 : −7 : −16) (88 : 27 : 4) (17777477 : 17737242 : 10386431) on the conic through (0 : 1 : 0) (9 : −2 : 0) (18 : −28 : 39) (110 : −54 : 57) (114 : −56 : 57) (17957226 : −2297946 : −3810025) on the conic through (0 : 1 : 0) (6 : 2 : −1) (3 : 11 : 2) (12 : −66 : 19) (36 : 94 : 33) (234946359 : 230213323 : 94637500) on the conic through (2 : 2 : 1) (0 : 1 : −3) (15 : 16 : 3) (28 : 63 : 34) (88 : 27 : 4)
P<x,y,z> := ProjectiveSpace(Rationals(), 2);
F := -18*x^4 - 45*x^3*y + 312*x^3*z + 176*x^2*y^2 + 439*x^2*y*z + 1066*x^2*z^2 + 63*x*y^3 - 2273*x*y^2*z + 470*x*y*z^2 - 1192*x*z^3 + 102*y^3*z + 1786*y^2*z^2 - 928*y*z^3 - 504*z^4;
C := Curve(P, F);
IsNonsingular(C);
pts := [[0,1,0], [2,2,1], [0,1,-3], [1,-3,0], [1,0,-3], [6,2,-1], [7,3,0], [7,7,4], [2,8,1], [9,-2,0], [9,9,2], [2,2,-11], [3,11,2], [11,-3,9], [5,12,5], [13,-9,1], [5,-7,-16], [15,16,3], [0,14,17], [0,18,-1], [22,4,19], [25,-12,9], [25,24,7], [9,-16,27], [11,29,10], [14,30,3], [11,32,25], [32,3,-9], [34,-14,25], [16,37,17], [18,-28,39], [17,-7,-44], [54,-26,7], [60,58,21], [28,63,34], [12,-66,19], [66,-4,3], [70,-6,-17], [30,-48,71], [29,74,7], [12,74,75], [3,23,-76], [65,81,12], [88,27,4], [36,94,33], [100,42,1], [90,104,17], [41,-109,58], [110,-54,57], [114,-56,57], [114,-20,3], [115,-53,26], [119,-42,93], [123,-2,6], [124,54,-3], [129,-21,-23], [31,-140,47], [140,-67,49], [146,140,97], [175,111,142], [190,162,141], [201,-199,12], [89,206,127], [60,-222,-1], [225,29,12], [235,49,-58], [94,244,23], [284,-61,2], [287,-148,31], [300,-22,-75], [50,-208,-319], [387,-181,108], [130,406,103], [413,-42,-96], [430,88,371], [455,84,-117], [165,478,139], [490,6,423], [494,194,13], [93,-322,-516], [33,-518,75], [603,248,-51], [605,587,151], [666,662,399], [690,196,33], [723,-579,50], [147,797,786], [802,-686,53], [70,-854,143], [890,312,-135], [891,-488,87], [913,348,-111], [682,-938,31], [608,-1219,16], [1245,497,1056], [530,1284,855], [1578,152,1365], [880,-1743,1261], [140,1641,1818], [1830,978,1519], [1952,42,-549], [578,1956,425], [2054,116,107], [2148,-967,1469], [2162,-1512,165], [1204,-1830,2193], [2346,2032,1725], [910,-552,-2361], [804,2534,237], [2562,-602,-75], [2565,-36,-703], [2610,118,135], [2795,1134,-258], [940,3358,329], [3474,4216,645], [4365,-2566,390], [1347,5047,516], [5271,-1084,-637], [5535,88,4779], [3210,-6486,4585], [2030,7086,1443], [7743,-4045,816], [8041,-1688,-913], [288,-8062,-81], [2023,8073,969], [1036,-8414,-103], [9709,6739,7742], [12710,12432,8091], [15105,6548,-159], [8773,16798,1771], [782,-17022,-189], [5170,18996,1903], [20520,-8309,15228], [22617,-5243,-1404], [23430,-11228,8305], [11891,-18763,27025], [18655,31489,3577], [10208,32502,3045], [33380,-25093,2414], [11590,38868,8601], [42880,25998,35041], [46151,-21228,9899], [21994,-50934,31065], [54560,-12838,-2189], [5550,15042,-58349], [30010,80346,7533], [35002,86682,33741], [88145,-12811,2992], [30330,-146628,-1249], [166662,2920,-46781], [168610,-36008,-18031], [235053,-118247,26784], [305361,-415984,14013], [388722,626864,73473], [188025,696952,123261], [1119670,1462758,205639], [2311175,953156,36883], [2674154,-1292200,342113], [4612393,4462668,3012729], [6312380,-3135237,742599], [2697149,6388905,2746848], [8339243,-15986565,12027486], [17777477,17737242,10386431], [17957226,-2297946,-3810025], [234946359,230213323,94637500], [1286041472,3839690670,1057598289]];
#{ C ! p : p in pts }; // 166