[Newsletter.]
 


February 2004

Candidate: Vladimir Bozin Abstract: In this work, we study geometry of Ricci-flat Kähler manifolds, and also provide some counterexample constructions. We study asymptotic behavior of complete Ricci-flat metrics at infinity and consider a construction of approximate Ricci-flat metrics on quasiprojective manifolds with a divisor with normal crossings removed, by means of reducing torsion of a non-Kähler metric with the right volume form. Next, we study special Lagrangian fibrations using methods of geometric function theory. In particular, we generalize the method of extremal length and prove a generaliziation of the Teichmüller theorem. We relate extremal problems to the existence of special Lagrangian fibrations in the large complex structure limit of Calabi-Yau manifolds. We proceed to some problems in the theory of minimal surfaces, disproving the Schoen-Yau conjecture and providing a first example of a proper harmonic map from the unit disk to a complex plane. In the end, we prove a strengthened version of the union closed set conjecture, giving a construction which might lead to a counterexample.
Title: Geometry of Ricci-flat Kähler manifolds and some counterexamples
Date: Saturday, February 14, 2004
Time: 1 pm
Location: Room 2-132
Committee: Gang Tian, thesis advisor
Victor Guillemin
Daniel Kleitman


March 2004

Candidate: Rados Radoicic Abstract: The work presented in this thesis falls under the broad umbrella of combinatorics of Erdös type. We describe diverse facets of interplay between geometry and combinatorics and consider several questions about existence of structures in various combinatorial settings. We make contributions to specific problems in combinatorial geometry, Ramsey theory and graph theory.

       First, we study extremal questions in geometric graph theory. We investigate the existence of collections of edges with a specified crossing pattern in drawings of graphs in the plane with sufficiently many edges. Among other results, we prove that any drawing of a graph on n vertices and Cn edges, where C is a sufficiently large constant, contains each of the following crossing patterns: (1) three pairwise crossing edges, (2) two edges that cross and are crossed by k other edges, (3) an edge crossed by four other edges. In the latter, we show that C = 5.5 is the best possible constant, which, through Székely's method, gives the best known value for a constant in the well known "Crossing Lemma" due to Ajtai, Chvátal, Leighton, Newborn and Szemerédi. After relaxing graph planarity in several ways, we proceed to study excr (n, C4), the maximum number of edges in a drawing of a graph on n vertices without self-crossing copy of C4. We prove that excr(n, C4) = O(n8/5). The importance of this and the above mentioned results comes from numerous applications of "Crossing Lemma" and the bounds on excr (n, C4) in discrete and computational geometry (incidence and Gallai-Sylvester type problems, k-set problems, the distinct distances and the unit distance problems of Erdös, problems on arrangements of circles and pseudo-parabolas, questions on parametric and kinetic minimum spanning trees), number theory, and the VLSI design.

       Next, we initiate a new trend in Ramsey theory, which can be categorized as the rainbow Ramsey theory. Drawing a parallel with Motzkin's statement that "complete disorder is impossible", we prove the existence of rainbow/hetero-chromatic structures in a colored universe, under certain density conditions on the coloring. For example, we prove that every 3-coloring of the set of positive integers, such that each color class has the upper density >1/6, contains a rainbow 3-term arithmetic progression; this statement being a clear rainbow analogue of van der Waerden's theorem. We also consider rainbow counterparts of other classical theorems in Ramsey theory, such as Rado's and Hales-Jewett theorem. Additionally, we refute one geometric strengthening of van der Waerden's theorem, answering an open problem of Pach.

       We continue with improvements and contributions to two classical problems in Euclidean Ramsey theory: (1) Hadwiger-Nelson problem on the chromatic number of blackboard bold Rd and (2) the empty convex hexagon question of Erdös.

       We then turn to some Ramsey-type geometric questions and prove that there exists a positive constant such that every family cal F of n semi-algebraic sets in blackboard bold Rd has two subfamilies cal F1, cal F2 subseteq cal F with at least varepsilonn members such that every member of cal F1 intersects all members of cal F2 or no member of cal F1 intersects any member of cal F2. This result generalizes and extends previous work of Pach and Solymosi, and solves some open problems of Erdös, Hajnal and Pach. We combine our novel approach with Szemerédi's regularity lemma to solve a longstanding open problem of Erdös on the least diameter of an n-point separated set in blackboard bold R3 with many nearly equal distances.

       We also provide improvements for several problems on arrangements of lines in the plane, as well as make some contributions towards resolving a well known conjecture of Lovász in graph theory.

Title: Extremal problems in combinatorial geometry and Ramsey theory
Date: Thursday, March 4, 2004
Time: 1 pm
Location: Room 4-153
Committee: Janos Pach (NYU, Courant Institute), thesis advisor
Daniel J. Kleitman
Richard Stanley
Igor Pak
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Candidate: Etienne Rassart Abstract: Using tools from combinatorics, convex geometry and symplectic geometry, we study the behavior of the Kostka numbers Klambdabeta and Littlewood-Richardson coefficients clambdamunu (the type A weight multiplicities and Clebsch-Gordan coefficients). We show that both are given by piecewise polynomial functions in the entries of the partitions and compositions parametrizing them, and that the domains of polynomiality form a complex of cones. In the case of Kostka numbers, a very nice combinatorial and geometric object, the permutahedron, appears because for fixed lambda, the nonzero Klambdabeta consist of the lattice points in the convex hull of the Weyl orbit of lambda. By relating the complex of cones to a hyperplane arrangement, interesting factorization patterns were found in the polynomials giving the Kostka numbers close to the boundary of the permutahedron, as well as factorization patterns in the difference between polynomials of adjacent regions inside the permutahedron. The case of A3 is studied more carefully and involves computer-proofs. We relate the description of the domains of polynomiality for the weight multiplicity function to that of the domains for the Duistermaat-Heckman measure from symplectic geometry. This measure can be though of as a continuous analogue of the weight multiplicity function.

       As an easy consequence of this work, one obtains simple proofs of the fact the Kostka numbers KNlambda Nmu and Littlewood-Richardson numbers cNlambda NmuNnu are given by polynomial functions in the nonnegative integer variable N. Both these results were known previously but have non-elementary proofs involving fermionic formulas for Kostka-Foulkes polynomials and semi-invariants of quivers.

       Also investigated is a new q-analogue of the Kostant partition function, a specialization of which was used by Victor Guillemin, Shlomo Sternberg and Jonathan Weitsman to give a formula for the twisted signatures of coadjoint orbits. This q-analogue is shown to be given by polynomial functions over the relative interiors of the cells of a complex of cones. For type A, the twisted signature is also given by a specialization of the Hall-Littlewood symmetric polynomials.

Title: Geometric approaches to computing Kostka numbers and Littlewood-Richardson coefficients
Date: Tuesday, March 16, 2004
Time: 3 pm
Location: Room 2-132
Committee: Sara Billey, thesis advisor
Victor Guillemin
Richard Stanley
Alex Postnikov


April 2004

Candidate: Edward Early Abstract: The Greene-Kleitman theorem says that the lengths of chains and antichains in any poset are intimately related via an integer partition, but very little is known about the partition λ(P) for most posets P. Our first goal is to develop a method for calculating values of λ(P) for certain posets. We find the size of the largest union of two or three chains in the lattice of partitions of n under dominance order, and in the Tamari lattice. Similar techniques are then applied to the k -equal partition lattice. We also present some partial results and conjectures on chains and antichains in these lattices.

       We give an elementary proof of the rank-unimodality of L(2,n,m), and find a symmetric chain decomposition of L(2,2,m). We also present some partial results and conjectures about related posets, including a theorem on the size of the largest union of k chains in these posets and a bijective proof of the symmetry of the H-vector for 2 × n.

Title: Chain and antichain enumerations in posets, and b-ary partitions
Date: Tuesday, April 6, 2004
Time: 3 pm
Location: 2-132
Committee: Richard Stanley, thesis advisor
Daniel Kleitman
Jonathan Farley

Candidate: Ionel Popescu Abstract: We give a probabilistic proof of the Morse inequalities in the nondegenerate and degenerate case.

       For the nondegenerate case, the kernel associated with the Witten Laplacian has an expression via the Malliavin calculus. The first step is the analysis of this heat kernel at a point away the critical set. Using Markov property, an iteration procedure and estimates on exit times from balls, everything is reduced to the estimation of a solution to a parabolic initial-boundary problem on a ball in the Euclidean space which is handled by an explicit construction of a supersolution. For the closed to the critical set case, based on the same line of ideas one can reduce the computation to a harmonic oscilator problem.

       The case of the degenerate Bott-Morse function requires a bit more work due to the fact that the geometry near the critical submanifolds is in general not trivial. After some standard constructions, we have two choices of the connection around critical submanifolds. One is the Levi-Civita and the other is the Bismut's connection. The main step in this analysis is to prove that the heat kernels of certain operators with respect to Levi-Civita connection and the Bismut connection stay bounded when the parameters involved become large. This is achieved by a fiberwise version of the argument given in the nondegenerate case. Using the boundedness, one can prove the basic comparison between the heat kernels of various operators. Finally one can reduce the problem to a fiberwise harmonic oscilator.

Title: Morse Inequalities, a Probabilistic Approach
Date: Tuesday, April 6, 2004
Time: 3 pm
Location: 2-147
Committee: Daniel Stroock, thesis advisor
I. M. Singer
Victor Guillemin

Candidate: Nora Ganter Abstract: There is a formula by string theorists Dijkgraaf, Moore, Verlinde and Verlinde, expressing the orbifold elliptic genus of the symmetric powers of an almost complex manifold M in terms of the elliptic genus of M itself. I am going to explain how from the point of view of elliptic cohomology an analogous p-typical statement follows as an easy corollary from the fact that the map of spectra corresponding to the genus preserves power operations. I will discuss higher chromatic versions of the notion of orbifold genus, involving h-tuples rather than pairs of commuting elements, and explain under which conditions one can prove DMVV-type product formulas for these. Precisely, any genus induced by an H-map into one of the Lubin-Tate cohomology theories Eh has an orbifold version with such a product formula, and the formula depends only on h and not on the genus. It turns out that the natural home for these (higher chromatic) orbifold genera is the K(h)-local stable homotopy category. Using homotopy theoretic methods one proves an integrality result and shows that the de nition of orbifold genus is independent of the representation of the orbifold.

Title: Orbifold genera, product formulas and power operations
Date: Monday, April 12, 2004
Time: 4:30 pm (as part of Topology seminar)
Location: 2-131
Committee: Michael Hopkins, thesis advisor Haynes Miller
A. Johan de Jong

Candidate: Sergi Elizalde Abstract: This thesis concerns the enumeration of pattern-avoiding permutations with respect to certain statistics.

       Our first result is that the joint distribution of the pair of statistics `number of fixed points' and `number of excedances' is the same in 321-avoiding as in 132-avoiding permutations. This generalizes a recent result of Robertson, Saracino and Zeilberger, for which we also give another, more direct proof. The key ideas are to introduce a new class of statistics on Dyck paths, based on what we call a tunnel, and to use a new technique involving diagonals of non-rational generating functions.

       Next we present a new statistic-preserving family of bijections from the set of Dyck paths to itself. They map statistics that appear in the study of pattern-avoiding permutations into classical statistics on Dyck paths, whose distribution is easy to obtain. In particular, this gives a simple bijective proof of the equidistribution of fixed points in the above two sets of restricted permutations.

       Then we introduce a bijection between 321- and 132-avoiding permutations that preserves the number of fixed points and the number of excedances. A part of our bijection is based on the Robinson-Schensted-Knuth correspondence. We also show that our bijection preserves additional parameters.

       Next, motivated by these results, we study the distribution of fixed points and excedances in permutations avoiding subsets of patterns of length 3. We solve all the cases of simultaneous avoidance of more than one pattern, giving generating functions which enumerate them. Some cases are generalized to patterns of arbitrary length. For avoidance of one single pattern we give partial results. We also describe the distribution of these statistics in involutions avoiding any subset of patterns of length 3. The main technique consists in using bijections between pattern-avoiding permutations and certain kinds of Dyck paths, in such a way that the statistics in permutations that we consider correspond to statistics on Dyck paths which are easier to enumerate.

       Finally, we study another kind of restricted permutations, counted by the Motzkin numbers. By constructing a bijection into Motzkin paths, we enumerate them with respect to some parameters, including the length of the longest increasing and decreasing subsequences and the number of ascents.

Title: Statistics on Pattern-avoiding Permutations
Date: Thursday, April 22, 2004
Time: 3 pm
Location: 4-149
Committee: Richard Stanley, thesis advisor
Igor Pak
Ira M. Gessel (Brandeis University)

Candidate: Mohammad Mahdian Abstract: The facility location problem is a basic problem in combinatorial optimization. In this problem, we are given a set of clients and a set of locations to build facilities, together with an opening cost for each facility, and a connection cost between each client and each facility satisfying the metric inequality. The objective is to open a set of facilities and connect each client to an open facility so that the total cost of opening facilities and connecting cities to facilities is minimized. This problem lies at the basis of many operations research and network design problems. As the problem is NP-hard, much effort has been devoted to designing approximation algorithms for it. Due to the distributed architecture of many of today's technologies, recent interest has arisen in studying the facility location problem in a game-theoretic setting.

       The goal of this thesis is to develop new and better techniques for approximating facility location problems and studying them in a game-theoretic setting. In our main result, we introduce a novel technique and apply it to the uncapacitated facility location problem, achieving the best known approximation factor for this problem. We demonstrate the general applicability of this technique by applying it to several unrelated problems. Finally, we consider the facility location problem in a game-theoretic setting and prove tight bounds on schemes for dividing up the cost of a solution among players. More specifically,

  • We design several approximation algorithms for the uncapacitated facility location problem, one of which achieves an approximation factor of 1.52 in quasi-linear time. This is the best known approximation factor for this problem, and is very close to the hardness lower bound for the problem. To design and analyze the approximation factor of our algorithms, we introduce a variation of the primal-dual method, which we call dual fitting, in combination with a factor-revealing LP.
  • We apply our algorithms on several variants of the problem, including k-facility location (a common generalization of k-median and facility location), uniform fault-tolerant facility location, facility location with penalties, and robust facility location, improving the best previously-known approximation algorithms for these problems. We show how our algorithms combined with the notion of bifactor approximate reductions can lead to a 2-approximation algorithm for the soft-capacitated facility location problem, achieving the integrality gap of the natural LP relaxation of the problem. We also define a problem called universal facility location, which generalizes several variants of the facility location problem, and give the first constant-factor approximation algorithm for this problem using local search. Finally, we apply the standard primal-dual scheme to two other variants of the facility location problem, namely priority facility location and stochastic facility location, to obtain improved approximation factors.
  • We show the versatility of our techniques by applying them to the analysis of other algorithms. In particular, we analyze the approximation factor of algorithms for the cycle cover problem with short cycles (a.k.a. the lane covering problem) and the Steiner packing problem (a.k.a. the maximum capacity multicast problem), and the competitive ratio of an online buffer management algorithm using factor-revealing LPs.
  • We consider the facility location problem in a game-theoretic setting, and prove lower bounds on schemes for dividing up the cost of a solution among the clients. Our result combined with the scheme recently proposed by Pal and Tardos shows that 1/3 is the best possible approximation factor for any facility location cost-sharing algorithm satisfying the cross-monotonicity property. Our proof is based on a novel technique that we develop and apply on several other optimization problems such as vertex cover, set cover, matching, and maximum flows to derive tight lower bounds.

Title: Facility Location and the Analysis of Algorithms Through Factor-Revealing Programs
Date: Friday, April 23, 2004
Time: 2 pm
Location: 4-257
Committee: Daniel Spielman, thesis advisor
Michel Goemans
Santosh Vempala

Candidate: Michael Korn Abstract: In this thesis we study tilings of regions on the square grid by polyominoes. A polyomino is any connected shape formed from a union of grid cells, and a tiling of a region is a collection of polyominoes lying in the region such that each square is covered exactly once. In particular, we focus on two main themes: local connectivity and tile invariants.

       Given a set of tiles T and a finite set L of local replacement moves, we say that a region Γ has local connectivity with respect to T and L if it is possible to convert any tiling of Γ into any other by means of these moves. If R is a set of regions (such as the set of all simply connected regions), then we say there is a local move property for T and R if there exists a finite set of moves L such that every Γ in R has local connectivity with respect to T and L. We use height function techniques to prove local move properties for several new tile sets. In addition, we provide explicit counterexamples to show the absence of a local move property for a number of tile sets where local move properties were conjectured to hold.

       We also provide several new results concerning tile invariants. If we let ai(τ) denote the number of occurrences of the tile ti in a tiling τ of a region Γ, then a tile invariant is a linear combination of the ai's whose value depends only on Γ and not on τ. We modify the boundary-word technique of Conway and Lagarias to prove tile invariants for several new sets of tiles and provide specific examples to show that the invariants we obtain are the best possible.

       In addition, we prove some new enumerative results, relating certain tiling problems to Baxter permutations, the Tutte polynomial, and alternating-sign matrices.

Title: Geometric and Algebraic Properties of Polyomino Tilings
Date: Monday, April 26, 2004
Time: 3 pm
Location: 2-139
Committee: Igor Pak, thesis advisor
Richard Stanley
Daniel J. Kleitman

Candidate: Kári Ragnarsson Abstract: In this thesis we explore the possibility of defining the p-local finite groups of Broto, Levi and Oliver in terms of their classifying spaces. More precisely, we consider the question posed by Haynes Miller, whether an equivalent theory can be recovered by studying maps f: BS→X from the classifying space of a finite p-group S to a p-complete space X equipped with a stable retract t satisfying a form of Frobenius reciprocity. In the case where S is elementary abelian, we answer this question in the affirmative, by showing that under some finiteness conditions such a triple (f;t;X) does indeed induce a p-local finite group over S. We also discuss the converse in some detail for general S.

Title: Frobenius Transfers and p-local Finite Groups
Date: Monday, April 26, 2004
Time: 4:30 pm (as part of Topology Seminar)
Location: Room 2-131
Committee: Haynes Miller, thesis advisor
Michael Hopkins
Lars Hesselholt

Candidate: Wai Ling Yee Abstract: A Verma module may admit an invariant Hermitian form, which is unique up to a real scalar when it exists. Suitably normalized, it is known as the Shapovalov form. The collection of highest weights decomposes under the affine Weyl group action into alcoves. The signature of the Shapovalov form for an irreducible Verma module depends only on the alcove in which the highest weight lies. We develop a formula for this signature, depending on the combinatorial structure of the affine Weyl group.

Classifying the irreducible unitary representations of a real reductive group is equivalent to the algebraic problem of classifying the Harish-Chandra modules admitting a positive definite invariant Hermitian form. Finding a formula for the signature of the Shapovalov form is a related problem that may be a necessary first step in such a classification.

Title: Signature of the Shapovalov Form
Date: Friday, April 30, 2004
Time: 10:30 am
Location: Room 2-143
Committee: David Vogan, thesis advisor
Pavel Etingof
Alexander Postnikov


May 2004

Candidate: Max Lieblich Abstract: We construct and describe compactified moduli stacks of Azumaya algebras on a smooth projective morphism XS. These stacks are the algebro-geometric version of the (suitably compactified) stacks of principal PGLn-bundles and they also have strong connections to arithmetic. A geometric approach to the problem leads one to study stacks of (semistable) twisted sheaves. We show that these stacks are very similar to the stacks of semistable sheaves. This gives a way of understanding the structure of the stack of PGLn-bundles and its coarse moduli space in terms of fairly well-understood spaces. In particular, when XS is a smooth projective curve or surface over an algebraically closed field, our method yields concrete theorems about the structure of these stacks (at least as certain natural invariants are allowed to increase without bound). On the arithmetic side, we use the geometry and rationality properties of these moduli spaces to study a classical question about the Brauer group of a function field K, known as the ``period-index problem'': for which classes α in Br(K) of order n does there exist a division algebra D of rank n2 with [D]=α? We give an answer to this question when K is the function field of a curve or surface over an algebraically closed, finite, or local field and when α is an unramified Brauer class of order prime to the characteristic of K. In the general case, we relate the unramified period-index problem to rationality questions on Galois twists of moduli spaces of semistable sheaves.
Title: Moduli of Twisted Sheaves and Generalized Azumaya Algebras
Date: Monday, May 3, 2004
Time: 1 pm
Location: Room 2-151
Committee: A. Johan de Jong, thesis advisor
Michael Artin
Martin Olsson

Candidate: Natasa Sesum Abstract: Consider the unnormalized Ricci flow (gij)t = -2Rij for t ∈ [0,T), where T < ∞. Richard Hamilton showed that if the curvature operator is uniformly bounded under the flow for all times t ∈ [0,T) then the solution can be extended beyond T. In the thesis we prove that if the Ricci curvature is uniformly bounded under the flow for all times t ∈ [0,T), then the curvature tensor has to be uniformly bounded as well. In particular, this means that if the Ricci tensor stays uniformly bounded up to a finite time T, a Ricci flow can not develop a singularity at T. We will give two different proofs of that result. One of them relies on Hamilton's estimates on distance changes along the flow and the other one relies on the identities for reduced distances and the monotonicity formula for reduced volumes that has been introduced and proved by Perelman in [G. Perelman: The entropy formula for the Ricci flow and its geometric applications, math.DG/0211159].

Consider the Ricci flow (gij)t = -2Rij + (1/τ) gij on a closed, n-dimensional manifold M. Assume that a solution of the flow exists for all times t ∈ [0,∞) and that the curvatures and the diameters are uniformly bounded along the flow. We will prove that for every sequence ti → ∞ there exists a subsequence such that g(ti+t) converges to a metric h(t) and h(t) is a Ricci soliton. We will also prove that if one of the limit solitons is integrable, then a soliton that we get in the limit is unique up to diffeomorphisms and the convergence toward it is exponential.

We will also prove that in an arbitrary dimension, for a given Kähler-Ricci flow with uniformly bounded Ricci curvatures, for every sequence of times ti converging to infinity, there exists a subsequence such that (M,g(ti + t)) → (Y,gbar(t)) and the convergence is smooth outside a singular set (which is a set of codimension at least 4). Moreover, gbar(t) is a solution of the flow off the singular set. In the case of a complex dimension 2, for any sequence of times converging to infinity we can find a subsequence of times such that we have a convergence toward a Kähler-Ricci soliton, away from finitely many isolated singularities.

Title: Limiting behavior of Ricci flows
Date: Monday, May 3, 2004
Time: 4 pm
Location: Room 2-143 (as part of the Geometry Seminar)
Committee: Gang Tian, thesis advisor
Jeff Viaclovsky
Richard Melrose

Candidate: Victor Costeanu  
Title: On the 2-typical deRham-Witt complex
Date: Monday May 3, 2004
Time: 4:30 pm
Location: Room 2-131
Committee: Lars Hesselholt, thesis advisor
Michael Hopkins
Haynes Miller

Candidate: Hao Wu Abstract: In this thesis, we discuss the relation between the Euler number of a tight contact small Seifert space and the contact framing of Legendrian vertical circles in it, and apply this relation to classify up to isotopy tight contact structures on small Seifert spaces with e0≠ 0,-1,-2.
Title: Tight Contact Structures on Small Seifert Spaces
Date: Friday May 7, 2004
Time: 4:30 pm
Location: Room 2-131
Committee: Gang Tian, thesis advisor
Denis Auroux
Victor Guillemin

Candidate: Jacob Lurie Abstract: Derived algebraic geometry is a refinement of the classical theory of schemes, which is obtained by replacing the notion of a commutative ring by a suitable homotopy-theoretic generalization. The purpose of this talk is to explain the motivation for considering these generalizations, to describe how the theory may be set up, and to sketch some applications of these ideas.
Title: Derived Algebraic Geometry
Date: Monday, May 10, 2004
Time: 3 pm
Location: Room 1-135
Committee: Michael Hopkins, thesis advisor
A. Johan de Jong
Haynes Miller

Candidate: Frédéric Latour

      

Title: Representations of Cherednik algebras in positive characteristic
Date: Tuesday May 11, 2004
Time: 4 pm
Location: Room 2-147
Committee: Pavel Etingof, thesis advisor
Victor Kac
David Vogan

Other Thesis Defenses

Current Term Thesis Defenses
 
Summer 2005 Thesis Defenses
 
Spring 2005 Thesis Defenses
 
Fall 2004 Thesis Defenses
 
Summer 2004 Thesis Defenses
 
Spring 2004 Thesis Defenses
 
Fall 2003 Thesis Defenses
 
Summer 2003 Thesis Defenses
 
Spring 2003 Thesis Defenses
 
Fall 2002 Thesis Defenses
 
Spring 2002 Thesis Defenses