[Newsletter.]
 

April 2003

Candidate: Natasha Bushueva Abstract: Traditional finance theory has been focused on problems assuming specific price dynamics for securities. In this thesis we focus on two key questions in financial economics, i.e. portfolio allocation and option pricing, without assuming specific price dynamics.

       We consider the problem of determining bounds on the price of an option based on observable prices of other options and the no-arbitrage assumption. This problem has been addressed and solved for the case of European call options of a single maturity and a single underlying asset. In a multiple maturities case the existence of an equivalent martingale measure, which is responsible for securities prices, introduces much more difficulty to the problem, since then additional constraints must be imposed to guarantee the condition of martingale existence.

       We find exact bounds on the price of a European call option, if the set of priced options of different maturities is given. We also find exact bounds if the payoff function on the option is a piecewise linear function of the stock. We solve a similar problem in a two dimensional case. The methods developed for two-dimensional case are applicable to a multiple dimensional case, however the number of variables grows exponentially with the dimension.

       We also investigate how the optimal bounds in the one-dimensional case change, if, in addition to the set of observable prices, there is a condition on the variance of the underlying asset. We derive an exact solution for the tight upper bound on the variance and propose a polynomial time algorithm for obtaining the lower bound.

       In a portfolio allocation problem we prove that for large time horizons, there exists a myopic policy which leads to a distribution of the terminal wealth with the property that the probability of underperforming any other policy tends to zero as the horizon tends to infinity. We address the problem of maximization of the mean-variance function of the terminal wealth in a multi-period case. For general price dynamics of securities we propose a monte-carlo based method for the solution which is polynomial in the number of securities.

Title: Finance Without Price Dynamics
Date: Rescheduled
New Date: Thursday, April 3, 2003
Time: 2:00 - 4:00pm
Location: Room 56-154
Committee: Dimitris Bertsimas (Operations Research), thesis supervisor
Santosh Vempala (chairman of the examining committee),
Igor Pak

Candidate: Ryan O'Donnell Abstract: In this thesis we study the noise sensitivity of boolean functions. Let f : {0,1}n -> {0,1} be a boolean function, and let epsilon \in [0,1]. Suppose x \in {0,1}n is chosen uniformly at random and y \in {0,1}n is formed by flipping each bit of x independently with probability epsilon. The noise sensitivity of f (at epsilon) is defined to be Pr[f(x) not equal f(y)].

       We give a detailed study of the noise sensitivity of various classes of boolean functions, including tight estimates and constructions for threshold functions and monotone functions. We also give several new applications of noise sensitivitiy in computer science, including:

  • A general direct product theorem for hardness amplification, which allows us to prove that NP is (1/2 + o(1))-hard for polynomial circuits under a weak assumption.
  • New efficient learning algorithms for various classes of functions, including intersections and thresholds of halfspaces, DNF formulas (under random walk examples), and juntas.
  • Asymptotic analysis of a new coin-flipping problem with relevance to cryptography and error-correction.

Title: Computational Applications of Noise Sensitivity
Date: Friday, April 11, 2003
Time: 1:00 - 3:00 pm
Location: Room 4-231
Committee: Madhu Sudan (EECS), thesis advisor
Daniel Spielman (committee chairman)
Santosh Vempala

Candidate: Mikhail Alekhnovitch Abstract: The thesis considers two fundamental questions in propositional proof complexity: lower bounds on the size of the shortest proof and automatizability of propositional proof systems.

       With respect to the first part, we develop a new paradigm for proving lower bounds in propositional calculus. Our method is based on the purely computational concept of pseudorandom generator. Namely, we call a pseudorandom generator Gn:{0,1}n -> {0,1}m hard for a propositional proof system P if P cannot efficiently prove the (properly encoded) statement Gn (x1,...,xn) not equal b for any string b \in {0,1}m. We consider a variety of "combinatorial" pseudorandom generators inspired by the Nisan-Wigderson generator on the one hand, and by the construction of Tseitin tautologies on the other. We prove that under certain circumstances these generators are hard for such proof systems as Resolution, Polynomial Calculus and Polynomial Calculus with Resolution (PCR).

       As to the second part, we prove that the problem of approximating the size of the shortest proof within factor 2log1-o(1)n is NP-hard. This result is very robust in that it holds for almost all natural proof systems, including: Frege systems, extended Frege systems, resolution, Horn resolution, the sequent calculus, the cut-free sequent calculus, as well as the polynomial calculus. Our hardness of approximation results usually apply to proof length measured either by number of symbols or by number of inferences, for tree-like or dag-like proofs. We introduce the Monotone Minimum (Circuit) Satisfying Assignment problem and reduce it to the problem of approximating the length of proofs.

       Finally, we show that neither Resolution nor tree-like Resolution is automatizable unless the class W[P] from the hierarchy of parameterized problems is fixed-parameter tractable by randomized algorithms with one-sided error.

Title: Propositional Proof Systems: Efficiency and Automatizability
Date: Friday, April 11, 2003
Time: 3:00 - 5:00 pm
Location: Room 2-132
Committee: Daniel Spielman (committee chairman)
Madhu Sudan (EECS), thesis advisor
Michael Sipser

Candidate: Sarah Groff Raynor Abstract: We examine the regularity properties of solutions to an elliptic free boundary problem, near a Neumann fixed boundary. Consider a nonnegative function u which minimizes the functional
J [v] = integral \Omega (|\nabla u|2 + Q2 (x) \chi {u>0})
on a bounded, convex domain \W \subset Rn. This function u is harmonic in its positive phase and satisfies $|\nabla u(x)| - Q(x) along the free boundary \partial {u>0}, in a weak sense. We prove various basic properties of such a minimizer near $\Gamma \subset \partial \Omega$ on which \partial u / \partial \nu = 0 weakly. These results include up-to-the boundary gradient estimates on harmonic functions with Neumann boundary conditions on convex domains. The main result is that the minimizer u is Lipschitz continuous. The proof in dimension 2 is by means of conformal mapping as well as a simplified monotonicity formula. In higher dimensions, the proof is via a maximum principle estimate for |\nabla u|.
Title: Regularity of Neumann solutions to an elliptic free boundary problem
Date: Tuesday, April 15, 2003
Time: 2:00 - 4:00 pm
Location: Room 2-147
Committee: David Jerison, thesis advisor
Victor Guillemin
Hubert Bray

Candidate: Pavel Greenfield Abstract: We analyze the evolution of Laplace eigenvalues on a domain induced by the motion of the boundary. We apply our analysis to two problems:
  1. We study the equilibrium and stability of electron bubbles. Electron bubbles are cavities formed around electrons injected into liquid helium. They can be treated as simple mathematical systems that minimize the energy with three terms: the energy of the electron proportional to a Laplace eigenvalue, the surface energy proportional to the surface area of the cavity, and the hydrostatic pressure proportional to its volume. This system possesses a surprising result: an instability of the 2S electron bubbles.
  2. We compute the simple eigenvalues on a regular polygon with N sides. The polygon is treated as a perturbation of the unit circle and its eigenvalues are approximated by a Taylor series. The accuracy of our approach is measured by comparison with finite element estimates. For the lowest eigenvalue, the first Taylor term provides an estimate within 10-5 of the true value. The second term reduces the error to 10-7. We discuss how to utilize the available symmetry to obtain better finite element estimates. Finally, we briefly discuss the expansion of simple eigenvalues on regular polygons in powers of 1/N.
Title: Boundary Perturbation of the Laplace Eigenvalues and Applications to Electron Bubbles and Polygons
Date: Tuesday, April 15, 2003
Time: 4:00 pm
Location: Room 2-131
Committee: Gilbert Strang, thesis advisor
Rodolfo Rosales
Alan Edelman,
Gerald J. Sussman

Candidate: David Sheppard
Title: Towards Characterizing Morphisms Between High Dimensional Hypersurfaces
Date: Thursday, April 17, 2003
Time: 2:30 pm (last minute time change)
Location: Room 2-135 (last minute location change)
Committee: Johan de Jong, thesis advisor
Jason Starr
Steven Kleiman

Candidate: Caroline Klivans Abstract: In this thesis we study the class of shifted simplicial complexes. A simplicial complex on n nodes is shifted if there exists a labeling of the nodes by 1 through n such that for any face, replacing any node of the face with a node of smaller label results in a collection which is also a face.

       A primary motivation for considering shifted complexes is a procedure called shifting. Shifting associates a shifted complex to any simplicial complex in a way which preserves meaningful information, while simplifying the structure of the complex. For example, shifting preserves the f-vector of a complex but always reduces the topology to a wedge of spheres. Shifting has proved to be a successful tool for answering questions regarding f-vectors.

       While most of the previous results on shifted complexes are algebraic or topological in nature, we explore the combinatorics of shifted complexes. We give intrinsic characterization theorems for shifted complexes and shifted matroid complexes. In addition, we show results on the enumeration of shifted complexes and connections to various combinatorial structures.

Title: Combinatorial Properties of Shifted Complexes
Date: Thursday, April 24, 2003
Time: 2:00 pm
Location: Room 1-150
Committee: Richard Stanley, thesis advisor
Daniel Kleitman
Alexander Postnikov

Candidate: Roya Beheshti Abstract: We study the Hilbert scheme of lines on projective Fano hypersurfaces. The main result is that for a smooth Fano hypersurface of degree at most 6 over an algebraically closed field of characteristic zero, the Hilbert scheme of lines has always the expected dimension.
Title: Lines on Fano Hypersurfaces
Date: Thursday, April 24, 2003
Time: 2:30 pm
Location: Room 1-277
Committee: Johan de Jong, thesis advisor
Steven Kleiman
Michael Artin

Candidate: Peter McNamara Abstract: A popular theme in the theory of partially ordered sets (posets) is to uncover information about given posets by showing that they admit a particular class of edge labellings. Perhaps the most important such class is that of EL-labellings, which were defined by Anders Björner. We study a subclass of EL-labellings known as "Sn EL-labellings." Their definition has additional combinatorial appeal in that Sn EL-labellings of a poset are EL-labellings where the labels along any maximal chain of the poset form a permutation of the set {1,2,...,n}.

       Supersolvable lattices were introduced by Richard Stanley in 1972 and were shown to admit Sn EL-labellings. Examples include finite distributive lattices, the lattice of partitions of [n] and the lattice of subgroups of a supersolvable group (hence the terminology). We show that a lattice is supersolvable if and only if it has an Sn EL-labelling. As one of our tools, we introduce a naturally defined local action on the maximal chains of posets with Sn EL-labellings. We see that this action gives a representation of the Hecke algebra of type A at q=0. As a further desirable property, the character of this representation is closely related to the flag f-vector. We ask what other posets have an action with these properties and, in particular, we show that a finite graded lattice has such an action if and only if it has an Sn EL-labelling.

       These results can be used to prove that a graded lattice is supersolvable if and only if it has a maximal chain of left modular elements. We thus have three new characterizations of lattice supersolvability. In joint work with Hugh Thomas, we move to the more general setting of lattices that need not be graded and, furthermore, to posets that need not be lattices. We give appropriate extended definitions of Sn EL-labellings, supersolvability and left modularity, and we show that many of the above equivalences still hold.

Title: Edge Labellings of Partially Ordered Sets
Date: Friday, April 25, 2003
Time: 11:45 am
Location: Room 2-146
Committee: Richard Stanley, thesis advisor
Alexander Postnikov
J. Farley (Visiting Associate Professor)

Candidate: Alexandru Ghitza Abstract: In a letter from 1987, J.-P. Serre proves that the systems of Hecke eigenvalues given by modular forms (mod p) are the same as the ones given by locally constant functions ABx / Bx -> \bar{F}p, where B is the endomorphism algebra of a supersingular elliptic curve. After giving a detailed exposition of Serre's result, we prove that the systems of Hecke eigenvalues given by Siegel modular forms (mod p) of genus g are the same as the ones given by algebraic modular forms (mod p) on the group GUg(B), as defined by B. Gross. The correspondence is obtained by restricting to the superspecial locus of the moduli space of abelian varieties.
Title: Siegel modular forms (mod p) and algebraic modular forms
Date: Monday, April 28, 2003
Time: 3:00 - 5:00 pm
Location: Room 2-139
Committee: Johan de Jong, thesis advisor
Michael Artin
Catherine O'Neil

Candidate: Alberto De Sole Abstract: Vertex algebras (VA) give a rigorous mathematical definition of the chiral part of a 2-dimensional quantum field theory.

       It is an interesting problem, both from a mathematical and a physical point of view, to classify VA's which are generated by a Virasoro element L, a space g of even primary fields of conformal weight 1 (currents) and a space U of odd primary fields of conformal weight 3/2.

       I will discuss a way to approach this problem and describe the solution in the case g is a simple Lie algebra and U an irreducible g-module. I will also show how, under certain assumption on the values of the Kac-Moody levels, one can prove transitivity of the group action on the sphere. This generalizes a similar result of Kac for the case of Lie conformal algebras.

Title: Vertex algebras generated by primary fields of low conformal weight
Date: Monday, April 28, 2003
Time: 4:00 pm
Location: Room 1-150
Committee: Victor Kac, thesis advisor
Pavel Etingof
David Vogan

Candidate: Ioana Dumitriu Abstract: The purpose of this thesis is to provide a more unified approach towards the random [beta]-Hermite and [beta]-Laguerre ensembles for arbitrary [beta]; previously, only the cases [beta]=1,2,4 were well studied.

       In this thesis we construct tridiagonal matrix models for the general ([beta] > 0) [beta]-Hermite and ([beta] > 0, a > [beta] (m-1) / 2) [beta]-Laguerre ensembles, and investigate applications of these new ensembles, particularly in the areas of eigenvalue statistics. Using these models, we obtain Strong Laws of Large Numbers and first and second order perturbation theory for large [beta], for all [beta]-Hermite and [beta]-Laguerre ensembles. In addition to this, we study the [beta]-ensembles in connection with Jack and Multivariate Orthogonal Polynomials, and obtain a duality principle.

       The thesis also contains an analysis of our Maple Library (MOPs: Multivariate Orthogonal Polynomials symbolically) which implements some new and some known algorithms for computing the Jack, Hermite, Laguerre, and Jacobi multivariate polynomials for arbitrary [beta]. This library can be used as a tool for conjecture-formulation and testing, for graphics, for statistical computations, or simply for getting acquainted with the mathematical concepts.

Title: Eigenvalue Statistics for Beta-Ensembles
Date: Tuesday, April 29, 2003
Time: 11:00 am
Location: Room 3-343
Committee: Alan Edelman, thesis advisor
Gilbert Strang
David Jackson (University of Waterloo)
Daniel Spielman

Candidate: Gyula Lakos
Title: Smooth K-theory and locally convex algebras
Date: Tuesday, April 29, 2003
Time: 4:30 pm
Location: Room 2-143
Committee: Richard Melrose, thesis advisor
Victor Guillemin
Andras Vasy
Michael Hopkins

May 2003

Candidate: Brett Altschul Abstract: We consider four problems in (1+1)-dimensional physics. Each of these problems had important connections to the physical behavior of (3+1)-dimensional systems. First, we consider problem of fermions interacting with multiple bosonic solitons. We describe a new approximation scheme for determining the fermion energy spectrum and apply it to (1+1)-dimensional two-component fermions coupled to scalar field solitons. Second, we study (1+1)-dimensional behavior in particles falling toward a Schwarzchild black hole. Using a non-covariant choice for the momentum cutoff, we examine the photon self-energy integral. We find evidence that the photons acquire an effective mass with a nonzero imaginary part, so that the photons may decay. Third, we consider cold fermions trapped in a high aspect ratio potential, which confines the particles to move in only one direction. The purely (1+1)-dimensional aspects of this problem have been extensively studied. We examine the corrections that arise because of the underlying (3+1)-dimensional character of the situation and determine the zero-temperature shifts in the (1+1)-dimensional energy spectrum. Fourth, we present a toy model, which is related, by analogy to the problem of electron-inhabited bubbles in liquid helium. An analysis of the 1-dimensional model suggests that the recent suggestion that the electron bubbles may split in two is incorrect.
Title: Aspects of Quantum Theory in 1+1 and Slightly More Dimensions
Date: Thursday, May 1, 2003
Time: 10:00 am
Location: Room 8-302
Committee: Roman Jackiw (Physics), thesis advisor
Daniel Freedman (committee chair)
Hung Cheng

Candidate: Grigore R. Tataru
Title: Adiabatic limit and Szego projections
Date: Friday, May 2, 2003
Time: 1:00 pm
Location: Room 4-231
Committee: Richard Melrose, thesis advisor
Victor Guillemin
Tomasz Mrowka

Candidate: Baochi Nguyen Abstract: The thesis gives a comprehensive study of elastic instability in growing yeast colonies and thin sheets. The differential adhesion between cells is believed to be the major driving force behind the formation of tissues. The idea is that an aggregate of cells minimizes the overall adhesive energy between cell surfaces. We demonstrate in a model experimental system that there exist conditions where a slowly growing tissue does not minimize this adhesive energy. A mathematical model demonstrates that the instability of a spherical shape is caused by the competition between elastic and surface energies. The mechanism is similar to the Asaro-Tiller instability in prestressed solids. We also study the buckling of a highly constrained thin elastic plate under edge compression. The plate is clamped lengthwise on two edges and constrained by foam pieces along one of the shorter edges. The remaining edge is free. Applying uniform compression along the clamped edges generates a cascade of parabola like curved singularities. In the case of single singularity, experimental study reveals a 1/3 power law for the distance between the foam foundation to the tip of the singularity as a function of compressed distance . We applies the theories pioneered by Pogorelov, who showed that any zero gaussian curvature surfaces are solutions of the von Karman equations. When two such surfaces intersect, the adjoin surfaces remains a solution everywhere except at the boundary of intersection. However, for small plate thickness and the asymptotic limit, it is possible to construct a solution for the boundary. The total energy of the solution is then given as the sum of the energy of individual surfaces and the boundary energy. We demonstrate that by intersecting a cone and a cylinder the deformation of a single curved singularity is entirely determined.
Title: Experimental and Theoretical Studies of Elastic Instability in Growing Yeast Colonies and Thin Sheets
Date: Friday, May 9, 2003
Time: 10:00 am
Location: Room 8-404
Committee: Michael Brenner (Harvard), thesis advisor
Rodolfo Rosales, committee chairman
Alexander van Oudenaarden (Physics)
Martin Bazant

Other Thesis Defenses

Current Term Thesis Defenses
 
Summer 2005 Thesis Defenses
 
Spring 2005 Thesis Defenses
 
Fall 2004 Thesis Defenses
 
Summer 2004 Thesis Defenses
 
Spring 2004 Thesis Defenses
 
Fall 2003 Thesis Defenses
 
Summer 2003 Thesis Defenses
 
Spring 2003 Thesis Defenses
 
Fall 2002 Thesis Defenses
 
Spring 2002 Thesis Defenses